TCC coaches have no love for NJSIAA tennis tournament format

0
17
Woodstown coach Jesse Stemberger talks with one of his players during a break in one of their NJSIAA girls tennis tournament matches in October.

Pennsville AD to speak on behalf of league coaches about reduced opportunities, increased costs and travel in two-section format

The NJSIAA thought it was doing a good thing by streamlining the format for its boys and girls tennis tournament this year, but one South Jersey conference will ask the governing body later today to switch it back, saying the new approach has created more hardships than it was intended to ease.

This year, the state changed its bracketing system to a two super-section draw (North and South) from the traditional four regions of South, Central and North I & II.

Pennsville athletics director Jamy Thomas, representing the Tri-County Conference and its “very upset” tennis coaches, will make a proposal at today’s end-of-season review in Robbinsville that the NJSIAA restore the four-region tournament format beginning with the boys event in the spring and lower entry fees for girls tennis beginning in 2027.

The TCC says the current format produced a larger individual tournament bracket, but fewer public school teams made the 24-team girls playoff bracket and the entry fee for the tournament increased significantly. The new format also increased travel demands.

“The biggest thing from the tennis coaches is you’re taking opportunities away from kids,” said Thomas, the TCC chair for boys and girls tennis. “You look at the numbers that we presented and their idea was this is going to get more teams involved, there’s a bunch of teams opting out of the playoffs, well that didn’t happen. This got less teams into the playoffs in every single gorup other than Group 2, which stayed the same. Teams weren’t opting out, we were actually playing. 

“I think this boils down to the North, and even some of the Central schools, they think they’re better than us, so they’re the powerful teams. They have the tennis facilities, they have indoor courts, they have all that. We don’t have that in South Jersey. Our kids are just tough, gritty kids who play good tennis, but they play it during the season. They’re not playing in the winter and things like that when these other kids are. They don’t have private coaches; they have our coaches.

“It’s like they want an opportunity to put more of their good teams in the higher games of the playoffs. C’mon, win your section and then come play our section. There are times our section beats the Central. We’ve won state in girls tennis. We’ve won it a few times.”

After taking a deep dive into this year’s girls tournament, the TCC discovered the switch from four sections to two, approved in a three-piece blanket of legislation in April, reduced the number of teams in the field from 215 to 192. No group gained playoff berths, but Group 1 alone accounted for 12 of the 23 fewer spots.

The entry fee increased by $80, increasing revenue to the NJSIAA despite a reduced number of schools in the field by $12,600. The conference will ask the NJSIAA to share actual receipts and comparable tournament costs.

NJSIAA officials acknowledged the additional travel when the change was reported upon last summer, but that had been the case in other sports and countered that it would “infuse additional excitement” into the draw with some “really good anticipated or potential matchups.”

Sounded good in theory, in practice it created some long — and in some cases scrapped — bus rides. In the South brackets, the estimated average round-tip increased from 72 to 94 miles in the first round and from 72 to 114 miles in the quarters. The new play-in round averaged 112 miles. All told, there were seven trips exceeding 150 round-trip miles this year compared to only one in 2025.

In this year’s South Jersey Group 1 tournament alone, there were play-in matchups between the 19th-seeded Henry Hudson/Keyport co-op and No. 14 Lower Cape May and No. 21 Wildwood traveling to No. 12 South River. Henry Hudson/Keyport didn’t even take the trip.

Closer to home, No. 10 Pennsville hosted No. 22 Dayton in another play-in matchup that was delayed a day at the visitors’ request. Had the seedings been reversed, Pennsville would have traveled to Dayton and, with the same result as the match (Pennsville won), then to No. 7 Woodbridge Magnet the next day.

“Travel seems to be a major issue for everyone, with a team from North Jersey forfeiting their match instead of making the drive,” Woodstown coach Jesse Stemberger said. “As a traditionalist and a purist, my preference would be to return to the four sections.”

Thomas can see a number of potential outcomes for his proposal. It’s his hope that it reverts to the former arrangement, even with the higher entry fee, perhaps even snaking the seedings like they’ve reverted to in football. One thing is certain: Reducing opportunities benefits no one.

“I want to support our coaches,” Thomas said. “They put a ton of time in and our kids, they should have these opportunities to win a South Jersey title and then go have a one-day chance to beat somebody from Central Jersey and from North Jersey and win a title. 

“When those teams are better than us and they beat us, great, but at least our kids got that experience to get to Mercer County and to play in that environment I don’t know why you’re playing that away from an entire section.”





LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here